I'll analyze the Simic Ritual archetype's performance with and without Shardless Agent, including matchup-specific data.
Now let me query the database to compare performance with and without Shardless Agent:
With Shardless Agent:
Without Shardless Agent:
The version with Shardless Agent performs substantially better and represents the vast majority (85%) of Simic Ritual entries.
Major improvements with Shardless Agent:
Matchups remain favorable with Shardless:
Problem matchups even with Shardless:
The data strongly suggests Shardless Agent is a core component of competitive Simic Ritual builds, particularly improving grindy matchups against Jeskai Blink and Goryo Reanimator.
Sources: Data from 93 tournaments (60% Melee, 40% MTGO). Recent examples: ReCQ Modern SCG CON, Sunday RCQ Modern